Meetingminutes Minutes15032017

Meeting commenced 13:00 PST

• Roll call (Tony C) - quorum achieved

Proposed agenda

• Roll call
• Review / approval of the agenda
• Review of previous meeting minutes (March 1, 2017)
• Deadlines (Tony C.)
  • V3.0
    • Items from PR comments on 2.4 - proposals required
      • Item 12 – make the doc match the header file (Chris Z)
      • Item 20 – might be replaced by work Dina is already doing (Dina K)
      • Item 13, 21 – provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Dina K)
      • Items 14, 15, 16, 18, 19 – provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Bob R)
      • Item 17 – provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Tim H)
  • EncryptCancel/DigestCancel/etc (Darren J)
  • Additional ECC Curves (Darren J)
  • Testing Profiles (Mark J & Anthony B.)
  • AEAD/AES GCM proposal/Extending Function Table/Forking (Bob R & Tim H)
  • Function table (Bob R)
  • CKM_AES_KEY_WRAP_PAD (Dieter B.)
  • KMIP Mappings (Tim H)
  • Associating Attributes to Wrapped Keys (Graham S)
  • DSA text improvements (Dina K, Bob R & Tony C)
  • TLS text improvements (Dina K)
  • CKM_NULL (Dina K)
  • C_LoginUser (Tim H)
  • IPSec Derive (Bob R)
  • Provisioning (Bob R)
  • SP-800-108 - KDF (Darren J)
  • Blockchain (David)
  • Additional ECC Curves (Darren J)
• Call for late arrivals
• Adjourn

Motion to approve Agenda

• Geoffrey H moves, Greg S seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions. Agenda approved.

Motion to approve meeting minutes

• March 1, 2017
• Tim H moves, Darren J seconds, no comments, objections or abstentions. Minutes approved.

Deadlines

• Reminder of May 1 deadline for ballot/motions on items to be included in v3.0

V3.0

Items from PR comments on 2.4 - proposals required

Item 12 – make the doc match the header file (Chris Z)

• No update

Item 20 – might be replaced by work Dina is already doing (Dina K)

• No update

Item 13, 21 – provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Dina K)

• No update

Items 14, 15, 16, 18, 19 – provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Bob R)

• No update

Item 17 – provide proposal for the proposed documentation content for header file items noted (Tim H)

• No update

EncryptCancel/DigestCancel/etc (Darren J)

• Geoffrey H - Review on this item opened a discussion on new vs changed APIs - use the init operation to clean up items in this space
• Tim H - asked how this would apply to "Find"
• Geoffrey H - confirmed that in most cases Init would be sufficient
• Tim H - Need a way to clear eveything in a session without the overhead of restarting the session. Most common usage is to kill off everything rather than specific items within a session
• Darren J - My context of usage ius a single item, unsure beyond that but a clean session does have significant value
• Bob R - Agree this would be useful
• All agreed that both approaches should be used - single item & whack eveything
• Updates to the Init functions with a NULL parameter meaning reset and Darren's existing proposal.
• Full review and motion at next meeting.

Additional ECC Curves (Darren J)

• No updates - have received feedback but have not applied it at yet

Testing Profiles (Mark J & Anthony B.)

• No updates

AEAD/AES GCM proposal/Extending Function Table/Forking (Bob R & Tim H)

• Tim completed review
• All 3 documents have been posted
• Only minor feedback received.
• Dieter provided some comments earlier today - contains both some editorial changes and some content changes regarding IVs and Nonce re NIST requirements.
• Dieter asked why the nonce needs to be generated by the token rather than an input token as NIST doesn't require it.
• BobR stated tht this is what NIST had asked for, but not specifically in the case of CCM
• Tim H indicated that we should allow for (but not prescribe) the nonce being generated by the token
• Bob R to update spec/proposal to allow two approaches (pass in nonce from application or generate in token)
• Please get any comments in so we can ballot/motion this on next call

CKM_AES_KEY_WRAP_PAD (Dieter B.)

• Will provie proposal for next meeting

KMIP Mappings (Tim H)

• No update

Associating Attributes to Wrapped Keys (Graham S)

• No update

DSA text improvements (Dina K, Bob R & Tony C)

• Dina to upload change
• BobR to allocate an ID

TLS text improvements (Dina K)

• No update

CKM_NULL (Dina K)

• No Update

C_LoginUser (Tim H)

• No update

IPSec Derive (Bob R)

• No update

Provisioning (Bob R)

• No update

SP-800-108 - KDF (Darren J)

• Initial draft for content review has been posted

Blockchain (David)

• Still working on content

New item - call numbers

• BobR has additional information form local numbers and a web dial in - Bob will send them around

Call for late arrivals

• 2 arrivals noted

Motion to Adjourn

• Tim H Moves, David seconds, No objections, no comments, no abstentions. Meeting adjourned.

Meeting Adjourned at 13:41 PST