MeetingMinutes20230913

September 13, 2023 Meeting Minutes

Meeting commenced 1:02 PM PDT

• Roll call (Bob) – quorum achieved.
• Greg S taking minutes.

Attendance

• Attendance noted in KAVI

Proposed agenda

• Roll call
• Review / approval of the agenda
• Approve Minutes (August 30, 2023)
• PKCS#11 v3.2
  • • Work Items
    • Action Items
    • Work Items Deferred from 3.1
    • Public Comments Items
• New Business
• Next meeting
• Call for late arrivals
• Adjourn

Motion to approve Agenda

• Motion: That the agenda for this meeting be approved.
• Moved: Tim H. Seconded: Valerie F. No objections, abstentions or comments. Agenda approved.

Motion to approve Minutes (August 30, 2023)

• Motion: That the minutes posted for August 30, 2023 be approved.
• Moved: Valerie F moved. Seconded: Tim H. No objections, abstentions or comments. Minutes approved.

PKCS#11 v3.2

• Items tracked in Wiki

3.2 Work Items

• Item #3 - No update
• Item #6.1 Kem Algorithms - Updated proposal posted on 30-Aug-2023, please review as we are planning to vote on Kem Algorithms Draft 4 at next meeting.
• Item #6.3 Post Quantum Signatures - Updated proposal posted on 30-Aug-2023, please review as we are planning to vote on Post Quantum Signatures V4 at next meeting.
• Item #9 - No update.
• Item 12 - Public/Private Key Linkage - Updated proposal posted on 1-Sep-2023, please review as we are planning to vote on Public Private Key Object Linking v2 at next meeting.
• Item 13 - Cross version compatibility approach - Discussion on mandatory items in new versions of the spec which may contain new items that will break existing implementations, for example implementing a new mandatory item when it did not previously exist or requiring a mandatory attribute when something created in an previous version does not have the mandatory item. Hamish C & Tim H temporary owners.

3.2 Action Items

• Action #6 - Interoperability issue using OAEP - Proposal posted on 11-Sep-2023 which amends sections 4.3.2 and 4.12.2 as discussed. Please review as we are planning to vote on Profile objects and C_FindObjects not consistent at next meeting.
• Action #7 - Discussion held to refresh issue - Spec should be updated to make this item clear.

Work Items Deferred Items from 3.1

• No items outstanding.

Public Comments Items

• PC Item #1 GCM and CCM Wrapping - HC working on a reply to DJ Comments
• PC Item #3 C_SetPIN - No Update.

New Business

• CKR_TOKEN_UNINITIALIZED
  • • Specification does not appear to have a good error code for trying to access an existing, present, token that has not been initialized. Proposal posted on 12-Sep-2023.
    • Motion: That the proposal for CKR_TOKEN_NOT_INITIALIZED be accepted.
    • Moved: Jonathan S. Seconded: Valerie F. No objections, abstentions or comments. Proposal Accepted.
• PKCS11-UG (Usage Guide) - Last version was in Version 2.40. Decision was made to remove link to the Usage guide in 3.1 but some of the references remain. Work Item for Usage Guide to be added in Wiki, in the meantime the original Usage Guide for V2.4 should be reviewed and a decision made on this work item as we move forward if we can include this in the next version as informative section.
• Starter Documents for PKCS11 V3.2 have been requested from TC Admin.

Next Meeting

• Motion: Next meeting will be September 27.
• Moved: Tim H. Seconded: Tony C. No objections, abstentions, or comments. Motion passed.

Call for Late Arrivals

• None

Motion to Adjourn

• Motion: That the meeting be adjourned.
• Moved: Tim H. Seconded: Hamish C. No objections, abstentions, or comments. Meeting adjourned.
• Meeting Adjourned at 1:52 PM PDT