-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 24
Meetingminutes Minutes07022018
Bob Relyea edited this page Mar 4, 2025
·
1 revision
- Roll call (Tony) - quorum achieved.
- Roll call
- Review / approval of the agenda
- Review of previous meeting minutes (January 10, 2018)
- V3.0 Items (Other business to be covered in the following meetings)
- Additional ECC Key Types Ballot
- Review Spec V3 from Chris Z
- Review Mechanisms V3 form Chris Z
- Planning for review/complete
- Proposal - Salsa20 & CHaCHa20 - Stef M
- Proposal - Blake2b - Stef M
- Proposal - X3DH & DoubleRatchet - Stef M
- Proposal - XEDDSA signateur mechanism - Stef M
- Revisit Function names
- Comment on comments list (Girish Kumar, CKA_TRUSTED). (Tony C) (https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/pkcs11-comment/201709/msg00000.html)
- Comments list query (Timo Teras, ETSI TS 103 097 certificates)
- Letter to NIST regarding AES GCM IV generation (Tony)
- PKCS#11 Repository (Tony C)
- PKCS#11 F2F Meeting (April 2018)
- New business
- Set next meeting date
- Call for late arrivals
- Adjourn
- Justin moved, Greg seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Agenda approved.
- January 24, 2018
- Daniel moved. Greg seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Minutes approved.
- Tony followed up with Chris Z. on placing his changes in the document.
- Darren sent some information to Chris, but hasn't heard back, yet. Also will be sending more comments today.
- Question on how to provide comments. Diff marked word document or text reply, just be sure to include page and section number.
- Bob wanted to send some feedback to Stef on the tables, but Stef hasn't seen them. Daniel Minder send Stef a few small notes on typos to correct.
- Daniel: we need to to decide on the direction on whether or not to include into 3.0, because we will need to update the old approved proposal to be compatible. Daniel proposes we wait to complete 3.0 until this is done, so all ChaCha things are right from release.
- Stef: I will make the changes as quickly as possible.
- Greg: yes, let's go very quickly.
- Tony: We are still waiting for Bob's comments, I will follow up with Bob and keep Stef updated. Also, will touch base with Chris to give him a heads up. Valerie also requested making it very clear where to put it - preferably with diffs. Any objections? None heard.
- Have not gotten any further reply, would appreciate feedback.
- Have not gotten any further reply, would appreciate feedback.
- Have not gotten any further reply, would appreciate feedback.
- Tony noted several members are on multiple committees, like KMIP, where we had the same argument multiple times, simply because someone did not receive the reply they wanted. not implying it is the case here, but that may explain why some were very short. We can certainly discuss.
- Daniel: Just suggesting to swap MessageEncrypt and EncryptMessage to make the same prefix for all things. Looks similar , and clear what all functions belong together. This will be a problem if you sort functions in your IDE, and it's done the same way in the rest of the document. Daniel can make the pass to make the change.
- Valerie recalls we had this discussion at F2F, but not the context. Tim recalls discussion as well, but Daniel could not find it in the minutes.
- Tim believes this was done to make it clear we were breaking/changing the behaviour. We always said we needed to change existing function names, but we hadn't done it.
- Tim doesn't disagree with the concept, but worried about the timing.
- Stef: message based functions are new to 3.0.
- Tony: Is anyone objecting to renaming the new AEAD functions to be consistent and consistent with older functions? Though those who have raised those objections are not on today's call.
- This was discussed in April 15, 2015 F2F: Minutes
- "In all instances the semantics are to change to ‘C_MessageEncrypt..’ – Init and Final should be changed to be consistent. (C_MessageEncrypt -> C_EncryptMessage & C_MessageDecrypt -> C_DecryptMessage) "
Comment on comments list (Girish Kumar, CKA_TRUSTED). (Tony) (https://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/pkcs11-comment/201709/msg00000.html)
- Tony is part way through a draft, will have it ready for the next call.
- Any volunteers to pick this up?
- Stef will look and get some more details. Valerie doesn't believe we've discussed it, and Stef will see if it's something we should.
- Stef got him online, Timo would like to propose adding new mechanisms. Tony clarified that he can indeed make it himself, just via the comments list.
- deferred.
- If you haven't, please let us know if you can make a F2F. It's not a vote for preference, but on availability.
- 69% of folks are voting for April 11, KMIP is 12th and 13th.
- Still looking for a volunteer to host for 15-25 people. Benton was looking into it, but not here today.
- none
- 21 February 2018.
- Jeff & Gerry.
- Greg moved. Gerry seconded. No objections, comments or abstentions. Adjourned.