What is the default behavior of vim here? Currently our jumpiest copies Zed's but I'd like to make it more useful.

I don't remember the default behavior, but in Vim there is keepjumps to skip adding entries to the jumplist.

The current implementation in zed seems to pollute the jumplist with every scroll up/down. The implementation in vim/neovim seems to ignore adding scrolling up and down to the jumplist with commands like ctrl-u, ctrl-d, ctrl-f, ctrl-b. Even if it didn't I would like to have the ability to ignore these since often i will do something like:

gd press ctrl-d a few times to scroll and then press ctrl-o to go back to before gd if that makes sense.

I think we can fix this by adding a flag to the editor to say "don't push to nav history" when we scroll. If anyone wants to pair with me on this: https://cal.com/conradirwin/pairing

Any update on this? It's kinda the only thing holding me back from using zed more often.

What is the default behavior of vim here? Currently our jumpiest copies Zed's but I'd like to make it more useful.

Stock Vim 9.1 (no plugins) doesn't update the jump list when scrolling up/down ctrl-u/ctrl-d. Zed recording these as jumps makes traversing the jump list with ctrl-o/ctrl-i much less useful for me.

Fixing this would probably make Zed fully compatible with my previous Vim workflow 🤞🏻