feat: A2A Protocol Integration Documentation & Implementation Plan #775
Conversation
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
- Consolidate 16 fragmented files into 6 well-organized documents - Create comprehensive README.md as main entry point - Merge redundant specifications into unified specification.md - Consolidate implementation plans into implementation-plan.md - Combine technical details into technical-reference.md - Unify analysis reports into analysis-report.md - Maintain types.ts and protocol-handler.ts unchanged - Eliminate duplicate content and inconsistent naming - Improve documentation structure and navigation - Preserve all important information while reducing complexity Files added: - README.md: Main entry point with overview and navigation - specification.md: Complete A2A protocol specification - implementation-plan.md: 4-phase refactoring strategy and roadmap - technical-reference.md: Detailed technical implementation guide - analysis-report.md: Comprehensive analysis and validation results - protocol-handler.ts: A2A protocol handler implementation - types.ts: TypeScript type definitions Benefits: - Reduced from 16 files to 6 files (62% reduction) - Eliminated redundancy and inconsistent naming - Improved developer experience with clear navigation - Easier maintenance with single source of truth - Better organization following documentation best practices
- Move A2A documentation from src/a2a-protocols/ to docs/reference/a2a-protocol/ - Rename branch from feature/a2a-protocol-docs-cleanup to feature/docs/a2a-protocol-integration - Update README.md with proper location information - Add A2A protocol reference to main docs INDEX.md - Follow proper documentation structure and naming conventions Changes: - Relocated 7 files to docs/reference/a2a-protocol/ - Updated docs/INDEX.md with A2A protocol reference section - Updated A2A README.md with location and status information - Proper branch naming following feature/docs/ convention Benefits: - Documentation follows repository structure conventions - Proper location in docs/reference/ alongside other protocol docs - Better discoverability through main docs index - Consistent with existing documentation organization
Contributor
Author
📝 Implementation Notes & CommentsDocumentation Cleanup ProcessThis PR represents a comprehensive cleanup and reorganization of A2A Protocol documentation:
Key Technical DecisionsArchitecture Consolidation Strategy
A2A Protocol Compliance
Claude-Flow Extensions
Implementation PhasesPhase 1: Foundation (Months 1-2)
Phase 2: Communication Consolidation (Months 3-4)
Phase 3: Memory Integration (Month 5)
Phase 4: Event Unification (Month 6)
Quality AssuranceDocumentation Standards
Testing Strategy
Risk AssessmentTechnical Risks
Business Risks
Success MetricsTechnical Targets
Business Impact
Next Steps for Reviewers
Questions for Discussion
This documentation provides a solid foundation for the A2A Protocol integration. The comprehensive analysis and detailed implementation plan should enable effective team review and decision-making. |
Contributor
Author
🔧 Technical Implementation DetailsA2A Protocol Handler ArchitectureThe core implementation follows the official A2A Protocol specification with Claude-Flow extensions: class ClaudeFlowA2AHandler implements A2AProtocolHandler {
// Core A2A methods
async sendMessage(params: MessageSendParams): Promise<Task | Message>
async getTask(params: TaskQueryParams): Promise<Task>
async cancelTask(params: TaskIdParams): Promise<Task>
// Optional A2A methods
async streamMessage?(params: MessageSendParams): Promise<StreamResponse>
async resubscribeTask?(params: TaskIdParams): Promise<StreamResponse>
// Claude-Flow extensions
async storeMemory?(key: string, value: any, namespace?: string): Promise<void>
async retrieveMemory?(key: string, namespace?: string): Promise<any>
async emitEvent?(event: ClaudeFlowEvent): Promise<void>
}Transport Protocol ImplementationThree transport protocols are implemented for maximum compatibility:
Agent Card StructureExtended A2A Agent Cards with Claude-Flow-specific capabilities: interface ClaudeFlowAgentCard extends AgentCard {
// Official A2A fields
protocolVersion: string;
name: string;
description: string;
url: string;
capabilities: AgentCapabilities;
// Claude-Flow extensions
claudeFlowVersion: string;
agentType: ClaudeFlowAgentType;
swarmCapabilities: SwarmCapabilities;
memoryIntegration: MemoryConfig;
supportsSwarmCoordination: boolean;
supportsMemorySharing: boolean;
supportsEventStreaming: boolean;
}Message Format MappingCurrent Claude-Flow messages are mapped to A2A format: // Current Claude-Flow message
interface SwarmMessage {
id: string;
type: string;
fromAgentId: string;
toAgentId: string;
content: any;
priority: MessagePriority;
}
// A2A Protocol message
interface Message {
role: "user" | "agent";
parts: Part[];
messageId: string;
taskId?: string;
contextId?: string;
kind: "message";
}Memory Integration StrategyMemory operations are integrated with A2A tasks: // Memory operations via A2A tasks
async storeMemoryViaA2A(key: string, value: any, namespace?: string): Promise<void> {
const task = await this.a2aHandler.sendMessage({
message: {
role: "agent",
parts: [{
kind: "data",
data: { action: "store", key, value, namespace }
}],
messageId: generateId(),
contextId: `memory-store-${namespace || 'default'}`,
kind: "message"
}
});
// Store as A2A task artifact
await this.storeAsArtifact(task.id, { key, value, namespace });
}Event System IntegrationEvents are mapped to A2A task status updates: // Event to A2A task state mapping
mapEventToA2ATaskState(event: SwarmEvent): TaskState {
switch(event.type) {
case 'task.created': return 'submitted';
case 'task.started': return 'working';
case 'task.completed': return 'completed';
case 'task.failed': return 'failed';
case 'agent.error': return 'failed';
default: return 'working';
}
}Performance OptimizationSeveral optimization strategies are implemented:
Error HandlingComprehensive error handling with A2A error codes: enum A2AErrorCode {
ParseError = -32700,
InvalidRequest = -32600,
MethodNotFound = -32601,
InvalidParams = -32602,
InternalError = -32603,
TaskNotFound = -32001,
TaskNotCancelable = -32002,
PushNotificationNotSupported = -32003,
UnsupportedOperation = -32004,
ContentTypeNotSupported = -32005,
InvalidAgentResponse = -32006,
AuthenticatedExtendedCardNotConfigured = -32007
}Security ImplementationSecurity features include:
Monitoring & ObservabilityBuilt-in monitoring capabilities: class A2AMetrics {
recordMessageSent(message: Message): void {
this.increment('messages.sent');
this.increment(`messages.sent.${message.role}`);
this.recordLatency('message.send', Date.now() - message.timestamp.getTime());
}
recordTaskCompleted(task: Task): void {
this.increment('tasks.completed');
this.recordLatency('task.duration', task.completedAt.getTime() - task.createdAt.getTime());
}
}Testing StrategyComprehensive testing approach:
This technical implementation provides a robust foundation for A2A Protocol integration while maintaining Claude-Flow's advanced capabilities. |
Contributor
Author
📝 Implementation Notes & CommentsDocumentation Cleanup ProcessThis PR represents a comprehensive cleanup and reorganization of A2A Protocol documentation:
Key Technical DecisionsArchitecture Consolidation Strategy
A2A Protocol Compliance
Claude-Flow Extensions
Implementation PhasesPhase 1: Foundation (Months 1-2)
Phase 2: Communication Consolidation (Months 3-4)
Phase 3: Memory Integration (Month 5)
Phase 4: Event Unification (Month 6)
Quality AssuranceDocumentation Standards
Testing Strategy
Risk AssessmentTechnical Risks
Business Risks
Success MetricsTechnical Targets
Business Impact
Next Steps for Reviewers
Questions for Discussion
This documentation provides a solid foundation for the A2A Protocol integration. The comprehensive analysis and detailed implementation plan should enable effective team review and decision-making. |
Contributor
Author
🔧 Technical Implementation DetailsA2A Protocol Handler ArchitectureThe core implementation follows the official A2A Protocol specification with Claude-Flow extensions: class ClaudeFlowA2AHandler implements A2AProtocolHandler {
// Core A2A methods
async sendMessage(params: MessageSendParams): Promise<Task | Message>
async getTask(params: TaskQueryParams): Promise<Task>
async cancelTask(params: TaskIdParams): Promise<Task>
// Optional A2A methods
async streamMessage?(params: MessageSendParams): Promise<StreamResponse>
async resubscribeTask?(params: TaskIdParams): Promise<StreamResponse>
// Claude-Flow extensions
async storeMemory?(key: string, value: any, namespace?: string): Promise<void>
async retrieveMemory?(key: string, namespace?: string): Promise<any>
async emitEvent?(event: ClaudeFlowEvent): Promise<void>
}Transport Protocol ImplementationThree transport protocols are implemented for maximum compatibility:
Agent Card StructureExtended A2A Agent Cards with Claude-Flow-specific capabilities: interface ClaudeFlowAgentCard extends AgentCard {
// Official A2A fields
protocolVersion: string;
name: string;
description: string;
url: string;
capabilities: AgentCapabilities;
// Claude-Flow extensions
claudeFlowVersion: string;
agentType: ClaudeFlowAgentType;
swarmCapabilities: SwarmCapabilities;
memoryIntegration: MemoryConfig;
supportsSwarmCoordination: boolean;
supportsMemorySharing: boolean;
supportsEventStreaming: boolean;
}Message Format MappingCurrent Claude-Flow messages are mapped to A2A format: // Current Claude-Flow message
interface SwarmMessage {
id: string;
type: string;
fromAgentId: string;
toAgentId: string;
content: any;
priority: MessagePriority;
}
// A2A Protocol message
interface Message {
role: "user" | "agent";
parts: Part[];
messageId: string;
taskId?: string;
contextId?: string;
kind: "message";
}Memory Integration StrategyMemory operations are integrated with A2A tasks: // Memory operations via A2A tasks
async storeMemoryViaA2A(key: string, value: any, namespace?: string): Promise<void> {
const task = await this.a2aHandler.sendMessage({
message: {
role: "agent",
parts: [{
kind: "data",
data: { action: "store", key, value, namespace }
}],
messageId: generateId(),
contextId: `memory-store-${namespace || 'default'}`,
kind: "message"
}
});
// Store as A2A task artifact
await this.storeAsArtifact(task.id, { key, value, namespace });
}Event System IntegrationEvents are mapped to A2A task status updates: // Event to A2A task state mapping
mapEventToA2ATaskState(event: SwarmEvent): TaskState {
switch(event.type) {
case 'task.created': return 'submitted';
case 'task.started': return 'working';
case 'task.completed': return 'completed';
case 'task.failed': return 'failed';
case 'agent.error': return 'failed';
default: return 'working';
}
}Performance OptimizationSeveral optimization strategies are implemented:
Error HandlingComprehensive error handling with A2A error codes: enum A2AErrorCode {
ParseError = -32700,
InvalidRequest = -32600,
MethodNotFound = -32601,
InvalidParams = -32602,
InternalError = -32603,
TaskNotFound = -32001,
TaskNotCancelable = -32002,
PushNotificationNotSupported = -32003,
UnsupportedOperation = -32004,
ContentTypeNotSupported = -32005,
InvalidAgentResponse = -32006,
AuthenticatedExtendedCardNotConfigured = -32007
}Security ImplementationSecurity features include:
Monitoring & ObservabilityBuilt-in monitoring capabilities: class A2AMetrics {
recordMessageSent(message: Message): void {
this.increment('messages.sent');
this.increment(`messages.sent.${message.role}`);
this.recordLatency('message.send', Date.now() - message.timestamp.getTime());
}
recordTaskCompleted(task: Task): void {
this.increment('tasks.completed');
this.recordLatency('task.duration', task.completedAt.getTime() - task.createdAt.getTime());
}
}Testing StrategyComprehensive testing approach:
This technical implementation provides a robust foundation for A2A Protocol integration while maintaining Claude-Flow's advanced capabilities. |
Contributor
Author
🚀 Additional Context & Next StepsRepository Status
Documentation Structure OverviewThe A2A Protocol documentation is now organized as follows: Key AchievementsDocumentation Consolidation
Content Quality
Architecture Analysis
Implementation ReadinessPhase 1: Foundation (Months 1-2)
Phase 2: Communication Consolidation (Months 3-4)
Phase 3: Memory Integration (Month 5)
Phase 4: Event Unification (Month 6)
Quality AssuranceDocumentation Standards
Technical Validation
Success Metrics & ValidationTechnical Targets
Business Impact
Immediate Next Steps
Long-term VisionThis A2A Protocol integration positions Claude-Flow as a leader in agent interoperability:
Questions for Team Discussion
This comprehensive documentation and implementation plan provides a solid foundation for transforming Claude-Flow's architecture while maintaining all current capabilities and adding industry-standard interoperability. |
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
A2A Protocol Integration Documentation & Implementation Plan
This PR introduces comprehensive documentation and implementation planning for integrating the official Agent2Agent (A2A) Protocol with Claude-Flow infrastructure. This represents a strategic shift toward industry standards while maintaining Claude-Flow's advanced enterprise capabilities.
What's Included
Documentation Structure (7 files)
Integration Points
Key Benefits
Architecture Simplification
Industry Compliance
Performance Improvements
Implementation Plan
Phase 1: A2A Protocol Foundation (Months 1-2)
Phase 2: Communication Consolidation (Months 3-4)
Phase 3: Memory System Integration (Month 5)
Phase 4: Event System Unification (Month 6)
Current Architecture Analysis
Before Refactoring (11+ overlapping systems)
Current Claude-Flow architecture has:
After Refactoring (1 unified A2A-compliant system)
Target A2A-compliant architecture:
Documentation Quality
Risk Mitigation
Success Metrics
Technical Metrics
Business Metrics
References
Next Steps
This PR establishes the foundation for transforming Claude-Flow's fragmented communication architecture into a unified, A2A-compliant system that maintains all current capabilities while adding industry-standard interoperability.