fix calendar generating start_date > end_date #78

miklcct · 2023-11-23T15:42:47Z

This prevents any calendar entries with start_date > end_date from leaking out by preventing them from being returned at the first instance.

fixes #76

linusnorton · 2023-11-23T16:29:43Z

Thank you for taking the time to write a patch. I don't have the latest data to hand - do you know why the end date before the start date? Given it's on the associated schedule (W27693_W28273) and not the cloned journeys I think the suspect logic would be:

calendar.clone(
  moment.max(this.calendar.runsFrom, calendar.runsFrom),
  moment.min(this.calendar.runsTo, calendar.runsTo)
),

I can't remember why we would use the calendar from the assoc train service (calendar) rather than the association itself. Logically I would say that the new service will only run for the duration of the association.

Does changing that code in mergeSchedules to this.calendar fix the issue?

miklcct · 2023-11-23T16:38:29Z

The original clone function accidentally mutates the parameters passed in (hence I have added two lines of .clone()) causing an invalid schedule, which I spent hours of debugging as the bugged schedule suddenly appeared and it didn't exist at the generation source.

After I added the two lines of .clone(), the original bug disappeared but a few pairs of [date+1, date] invalid ranges appeared.

The following is the raw data:

AANW27693W282732311132312011111100VVSCRDFCEN  TP                               P
AANW27693W282732311212311240111100   CRDFCEN  T                                C
AANW27693W282732311272312011111100   CRDFCEN  T                                C
BSNW276932311132312011111100 POO2M04    125442000 DMUS   075      S            P
BSNW282732311132312011111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            P
BSNW282732311142311240111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            O
BSNW276932311212311240111100 POO2M04    125442000 DMUS   075      S            O
BSNW276932311272312011111100 POO2M04    125442000 DMUS   075      S            O
BSNW282732311272312011111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            O
BSNW276932312042312081111100 POO2M04    125442000 DMUS   075      S            P
BSNW282732312042312081111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            P

and the CSV exported from the database

"id","train_uid","runs_from","runs_to","monday","tuesday","wednesday","thursday","friday","saturday","sunday","bank_holiday_running","train_status","train_category","train_identity","headcode","course_indicator","profit_center","business_sector","power_type","timing_load","speed","operating_chars","train_class","sleepers","reservations","connect_indicator","catering_code","service_branding","stp_indicator"
"60145","W27693","2023-11-13","2023-12-01","1","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2M04",NULL,"1","25442000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"P"
"63140","W27693","2023-11-21","2023-11-24","0","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2M04",NULL,"1","25442000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"O"
"84553","W27693","2023-11-27","2023-12-01","1","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2M04",NULL,"1","25442000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"O"
"101522","W27693","2023-12-04","2023-12-08","1","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2M04",NULL,"1","25442000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"P"
"60146","W28273","2023-11-13","2023-12-01","1","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2V02",NULL,"1","25447000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"P"
"60162","W28273","2023-11-14","2023-11-24","0","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2V02",NULL,"1","25447000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"O"
"84582","W28273","2023-11-27","2023-12-01","1","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2V02",NULL,"1","25447000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"O"
"101523","W28273","2023-12-04","2023-12-08","1","1","1","1","1","0","0","1","P","OO","2V02",NULL,"1","25447000",NULL,"DMU","S","075",NULL,"S",NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,NULL,"P"

"id","base_uid","assoc_uid","start_date","end_date","monday","tuesday","wednesday","thursday","friday","saturday","sunday","assoc_cat","assoc_date_ind","assoc_location","base_location_suffix","assoc_location_suffix","association_type","stp_indicator"
"428","W27693","W28273","2023-11-13","2023-12-01","1","1","1","1","1","0","0","VV","S","CRDFCEN",,,"P","P"
"441","W27693","W28273","2023-11-21","2023-11-24","0","1","1","1","1","0","0",NULL,NULL,"CRDFCEN",,,NULL,"C"
"694","W27693","W28273","2023-11-27","2023-12-01","1","1","1","1","1","0","0",NULL,NULL,"CRDFCEN",,,NULL,"C"

linusnorton · 2023-11-23T16:52:31Z

Thanks, I'm just wondering if it's possible to prevent the null returns in order to simplify the code

linusnorton · 2023-11-23T17:11:14Z

Matching up the associations and services with the overlays makes it look like the start date for W28273 is wrong:

AAN W27693 W28273 231113 231201 1111100VVSCRDFCEN  TP                               P
BSN W27693        231113 231201 1111100 POO2M04    125442000 DMUS   075      S            P
BSN W28273        231113 231201 1111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            P

AAN W27693 W28273 231127 231201 1111100   CRDFCEN  T                                C
BSN W27693        231127 231201 1111100 POO2M04    125442000 DMUS   075      S            O
BSN W28273        231127 231201 1111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            O

AAN W27693 W28273 231121 231124 0111100   CRDFCEN  T                                C
BSN W27693        231121 231124 0111100 POO2M04    125442000 DMUS   075      S            O
BSN W28273        **231114** 231124 0111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            O

At that point the min/max should kick in and the max of the start date should use the AA record start date and the start and end should come out as 231124. That would suggest the merged record is fine but then we will create another service for before the association:

    if (assoc.calendar.runsFrom.isBefore(assocCalendar.runsFrom)) {
      const before = assoc.calendar.clone(assoc.calendar.runsFrom, assocCalendar.runsFrom.clone().subtract(1, "days"));

      schedules.push(assoc.clone(before, idGenerator.next().value));
    }

I regret the naming of assoc and assocCalendar. assoc.calendar is the the assoc service and assocCalendar is assoc record itself.

The new before service should run from 231114 to 231121 - 1 day so I'm not quite sure how it still goes wrong.

Sorry for thinking out loud. I haven't touched this code in years and the "correct" behaviour is not always obvious.

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T09:41:36Z

@miklcct I think they have corrected the data this morning so that the runs_from field for:

BSN W28273        **231114** 231124 0111100 POO2V02    125447000 DMUS   075      S            O

Now matches the association record.

I'm inclined to merge the fix for the mutation bug you found but not the changes that allow null schedules.

miklcct · 2023-11-24T12:14:39Z

If I only fix the mutation bug it generates a GTFS with a few calendar ranges between Christmas and New Year with start_date being 1 day after the end_date, so I believe returning null from clone() is necessary, or disable the calendar tightening altogether.

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T12:24:08Z

I did a quick check with today's data and I couldn't find any cases where the start date was after the end date. What records are you seeing?

miklcct · 2023-11-24T12:43:36Z

I have just run the generator on the latest master branch with version 930 data, with only the two lines of .clone() added to fix the mutation issue.

Errors are generated as follows:
filename (?)The name of the faulty file. csvRowNumber (?)The row number of the faulty record. entityId (?)The faulty service id. startFieldName (?)The start value's field name. startValue (?)The start value. endFieldName (?)The end value's field name. endValue (?)The end value.
"calendar.txt" 156 "155" "start_date" "20231203" "end_date" "20231126"
"calendar.txt" 493 "492" "start_date" "20231208" "end_date" "20231207"
"calendar.txt" 539 "538" "start_date" "20231127" "end_date" "20231124"
"calendar.txt" 596 "595" "start_date" "20231204" "end_date" "20231201"
"calendar.txt" 886 "885" "start_date" "20231130" "end_date" "20231129"
"calendar.txt" 887 "886" "start_date" "20231130" "end_date" "20231124"
"calendar.txt" 888 "887" "start_date" "20231129" "end_date" "20231128"
"calendar.txt" 1037 "1036" "start_date" "20231206" "end_date" "20231129"
"calendar.txt" 1038 "1037" "start_date" "20231205" "end_date" "20231128"
"calendar.txt" 1090 "1089" "start_date" "20231209" "end_date" "20231202"
"calendar.txt" 1131 "1130" "start_date" "20231202" "end_date" "20231125"
"calendar.txt" 3230 "3229" "start_date" "20231214" "end_date" "20231213"
"calendar.txt" 3520 "3519" "start_date" "20240105" "end_date" "20231229"
"calendar.txt" 4531 "4530" "start_date" "20240126" "end_date" "20240119"
"calendar.txt" 4769 "4768" "start_date" "20240127" "end_date" "20240120"
"calendar.txt" 4801 "4800" "start_date" "20240120" "end_date" "20240113"
"calendar.txt" 4802 "4801" "start_date" "20240106" "end_date" "20231230"

The full report can be viewed here.

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T13:02:10Z

Ah it looks like your on the weekly feed. I'm on the daily which is 932

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T13:25:20Z

RJTTC931.ZIP
RJTTC932.ZIP

Try processing these after the 930

miklcct · 2023-11-24T13:43:20Z

Error still exist on version 932:
https://gtfs-validator-results.mobilitydata.org/9f2b4ecb-81c5-4ac6-9ee4-974989ed4507/report.html

filename (?)The name of the faulty file. csvRowNumber (?)The row number of the faulty record. entityId (?)The faulty service id. startFieldName (?)The start value's field name. startValue (?)The start value. endFieldName (?)The end value's field name. endValue (?)The end value.
"calendar.txt" 163 "162" "start_date" "20231203" "end_date" "20231126"
"calendar.txt" 240 "239" "start_date" "20231207" "end_date" "20231206"
"calendar.txt" 632 "631" "start_date" "20231127" "end_date" "20231124"
"calendar.txt" 640 "639" "start_date" "20231205" "end_date" "20231204"
"calendar.txt" 690 "689" "start_date" "20231204" "end_date" "20231201"
"calendar.txt" 696 "695" "start_date" "20231208" "end_date" "20231201"
"calendar.txt" 849 "848" "start_date" "20231208" "end_date" "20231207"
"calendar.txt" 1015 "1014" "start_date" "20231204" "end_date" "20231130"
"calendar.txt" 1034 "1033" "start_date" "20231130" "end_date" "20231129"
"calendar.txt" 1035 "1034" "start_date" "20231130" "end_date" "20231124"

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T14:20:24Z

I get a completely different set of data
gb-rail.zip

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T14:27:16Z

This is my 930: https://file.io/yK4ODhtZDv6b - is it the same as yours?

miklcct · 2023-11-24T14:37:01Z

Yes the files are the same. Have you added the two lines of .clone() in ScheduleCalendar.ts lines 113 and 114?

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T14:38:45Z

No, just running from master. I'll try again with the clone methods

linusnorton · 2023-11-24T15:36:32Z

That's so weird! Adding the clones, which I would expect to be fine then gives me the same results as you. I'll debug a bit further. Sorry this is taking so long.

An upstream bug causing pipeline failures [PR submitted to upstream](planarnetwork#78) Related work items: #951

miklcct added 2 commits November 23, 2023 15:34

fix calendar generating start_date > end_date

a3da83e

Merge branch 'master' into fix/calendar_out_of_range

35eb90c

miklcct added a commit to Jnction/dtd2mysql that referenced this pull request Jan 10, 2024

Merged PR 298: fix calendar generating start_date > end_date

96b75d1

An upstream bug causing pipeline failures [PR submitted to upstream](planarnetwork#78) Related work items: #951

miklcct closed this Dec 9, 2024

miklcct deleted the fix/calendar_out_of_range branch December 9, 2024 10:54

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

fix calendar generating start_date > end_date #78

fix calendar generating start_date > end_date #78

miklcct commented Nov 23, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 23, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 23, 2023 •

edited

Loading

linusnorton commented Nov 23, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 23, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023 •

edited

Loading

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023 •

edited

Loading

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

fix calendar generating start_date > end_date #78

fix calendar generating start_date > end_date #78

Conversation

miklcct commented Nov 23, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 23, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 23, 2023 • edited Loading

linusnorton commented Nov 23, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 23, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023 • edited Loading

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023 • edited Loading

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

linusnorton commented Nov 24, 2023

miklcct commented Nov 23, 2023 •

edited

Loading

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023 •

edited

Loading

miklcct commented Nov 24, 2023 •

edited

Loading