Conversation
cristipufu
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I've reviewed the PR which adds a new Docs Agent sample to the repository. Here's my detailed feedback:
Overview
This PR adds a new sample that demonstrates how to create a documentation agent using LangGraph and MCP adapters. The agent is designed to automatically write documentation for GitHub repositories based on user requests.
Code Structure
The sample is well-organized and includes:
main.py- Core agent implementationagent.mermaid- Flow visualizationlanggraph.json- Graph configurationpyproject.toml- Project dependenciesuipath.json- UiPath configuration.env.example- Environment variables template
Technical Review
Positive Aspects:
-
Well-Structured System Prompt: The documentation agent has a very detailed and well-organized system prompt that covers:
- Clear role definition
- Specific capabilities
- Structured workflow steps
- Documentation style guidelines
- Examples and templates
- Error handling scenarios
-
Clean Architecture:
- Uses LangGraph's prebuilt agent components effectively
- Clear separation of concerns between state management and agent logic
- Good use of async context manager for resource management
-
Proper Error Handling:
- Uses async context manager for proper cleanup
- Includes timeout in server connection
-
Dependencies:
- Clear specification of dependencies with version constraints
- Modern Python requirement (>=3.10)
- Uses up-to-date versions of key packages
Suggestions for Improvement:
- Environment Variables:
dotenv.load_dotenv()Consider making the .env file path configurable or adding error handling for missing environment variables.
- Type Hints:
TheIssueStateclass could benefit from more detailed type hints:
class IssueState(AgentState):
owner: str
repo: str
issueNumber: intConsider adding docstrings to explain the purpose of each field.
- Documentation:
- Add docstrings to the
make_graph()function explaining its purpose and return type - Consider adding inline comments explaining complex parts of the system prompt
- Add a README.md file for the sample explaining setup and usage
- Configuration:
The.env.examplefile should include all required environment variables. Currently missing:
UIPATH_ACCESS_TOKEN=***
Security Considerations:
- Good: Using environment variables for sensitive data
- Good: API keys and tokens not hardcoded
- Good: Proper timeout settings for server connections
Performance:
- Using Claude 3 Sonnet model - good balance of performance and cost
- Async implementation allows for efficient handling of I/O operations
Recommendations:
- Add a comprehensive README.md file
- Add error handling for missing environment variables
- Add more type hints and docstrings
- Consider adding unit tests for the agent
- Document memory usage and performance characteristics
Overall, this is a well-implemented sample that demonstrates good practices in building AI agents. The code is clean, well-structured, and follows modern Python development practices. The comprehensive system prompt is particularly impressive and should serve as a good example for similar implementations.
| from langchain_mcp_adapters.client import MultiServerMCPClient | ||
| from langgraph.prebuilt import create_react_agent | ||
| from langgraph.prebuilt.chat_agent_executor import AgentState | ||
|
|
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Consider adding type hints and a docstring to this class to improve code documentation and maintainability:
class IssueState(AgentState):
"""State for the documentation agent containing GitHub issue details.
Attributes:
owner (str): The GitHub repository owner (user or organization)
repo (str): The GitHub repository name
issueNumber (int): The issue number to process
"""
owner: str
repo: str
issueNumber: int|
|
||
|
|
||
| class IssueState(AgentState): | ||
| owner: str |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The make_graph function would benefit from a docstring explaining its purpose and return type:
@asynccontextmanager
async def make_graph():
"""Create and configure a LangGraph agent for documentation generation.
This function sets up an async context that:
1. Connects to the MCP server via SSE
2. Configures the Claude 3 model and tools
3. Creates a ReAct agent with documentation-specific prompt
Returns:
AsyncGenerator[Graph, None]: A LangGraph instance configured for documentation tasks
"""| @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ | |||
| ANTHROPIC_API_KEY=*** | |||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The .env.example file should include all required environment variables. Please add:
UIPATH_ACCESS_TOKEN=***
This variable is required by the code but not listed in the example.
No description provided.