Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

reassessment of actors, their affiliations, and relations to research product (versions) #513

Open
lzehl opened this issue Sep 26, 2024 · 0 comments
Labels
major update large workload or major update needed to complete

Comments

@lzehl
Copy link
Member

lzehl commented Sep 26, 2024

This issue is based on issues #502, #500 with additional aspects.

research products (RPs); research product versions (RPVs)
category legalPerson: Person, Organisation, Consortium

@openMetadataInitiative/openminds-developers please review and discuss (terminology is still up for change, please provide better suggestions if you have them)


Current status (as reminder)

Current status for linkages between RP/PRV and actors:

  • author (1-N) linked category: legalPerson (for some RP/RPV, e.g. dataset (version))
  • custodian (1/0-N) linked category: legalPerson (for any RP/RPV; required only in dataset (version))
  • developer (1-N) linked category: legalPerson (for some RP/RPV, e.g. software (version))
  • otherContribution (0-N) linked type: Contribution (for any RPV)

Current Contribution:

  • contributor (1) linked category: legalPerson
  • type (1-N) linked type: ContributionType (controlled, e.g. coordination, data processing, etc.)

Current linkage to Affiliation:

  • affiliation (0-N) linked type: Affiliation (for Person or Organisation)

Current Affiliation:

  • endDate (0-1) string (date)
  • memberOf (1) linked type: Consortium or Organisation
  • startDate (0-1) string (date)

Current Organisation:

  • affiliation (0-N) linked type: Affiliation
  • digitalIdentifier (0-N) linked type: GRIDID, RORID, RRID
  • fullName (1) string
  • hasParent (0-N) linked type: Organisation
  • homepage (0-1) string (iri)
  • shortName (0-1) string

Current Consortium:

  • fullName (1) string
  • contactInformation (0-1) linked type ContactInformation (email)
  • homepage (0-1) string (iri)
  • shortName (0-1) string

SUGGESTIONS:

  1. get rid of role specific actor linkages
  2. make affiliation for a specific RP/RPV explicit
  3. enforce real Organisation (with RORID); decouple department, institute, etc. info
  4. review Consortium (ID missing? affiliation missing?)
  5. review Person (full name?)

RP/RPV

  • replace "author", "developer", "otherContribution" with "contributor"
  • contributor (1-N) embedded type Contributor

New Contributor:

  • legalPerson (1) linked category legalPerson
  • contribution (1-N) embedded type Contribution
  • affiliation (1-N) linked type Affiliation

New Contribution:

  • role (1) linked type ContributorType
  • order (0-1) number (will require conditions to be checked)

New Affiliation:

  • organisation (1) linked type Organisation
  • institution (0-1) free text ? linked type ?
  • department (0-1) free text ? linked type ?
  • other ?

New Organisation:

  • acronym (0-1) string
  • alternateName (0-N) string
  • digitalIdentifier (0-N) linked type: GRIDID, RORID, RRID
  • fullName (1) string
  • hasParent (0-N) linked type: Organisation
  • homepage (0-1) string (iri)
  • memberOf (0-N) embedded type: Membership

New Person:

  • alternateName (0-N) string
  • associatedAccount (0-N) linked type AccountInformation
  • contactInformation (1) linked type ContactInformation
  • digitalIdentifier (0-N) linked type ORCID (others??)
  • familyName (0-1) string
  • givenName (1) string
  • memberOf (0-N) embedded type Membership

New Membership:

  • endDate (0-1) string (date)
  • memberOf (1) linked type: Consortium or Organisation
  • startDate (0-1) string (date)
@lzehl lzehl added the major update large workload or major update needed to complete label Sep 26, 2024
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
major update large workload or major update needed to complete
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant