Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
122 lines (89 loc) · 4.12 KB

BUSINESS-MODEL.md

File metadata and controls

122 lines (89 loc) · 4.12 KB

Business Model

Open core. The engine is free and AGPL-licensed; the things teams need at scale are paid.

This file exists so features do not land in the open repo by accident. Before building anything, check which column it belongs in.


Why AGPL-3.0

Distribution Free self-hosting is the only channel available without a brand, a sales team, or a marketing budget. SonarQube reached millions of installs this way before upselling.
Defence AGPL requires anyone running a modified version as a network service to publish their source. A competitor cannot take this and launch a hosted SonarQuest without opening their changes. Apache-2.0 would let them.
Revenue mechanism Large enterprises routinely prohibit AGPL in their dependency policy. "Our legal team will not approve AGPL" is a sales conversation, not a lost deal. The commercial licence is the answer.

The CLA is load-bearing. Without copyright grants from contributors, their code stays AGPL-only forever and cannot be included in a commercial licence. That would kill the model. See CLA.md.


Free (AGPL, self-hosted)

Everything needed to prove the tool works on a real codebase:

  • SAST via OpenGrep — full language coverage
  • SCA: dependency inventory, CVE matching, license identification
  • SBOM export (CycloneDX, SPDX)
  • Quality gates on the default branch
  • CLI scanner for any CI system
  • Single-project dashboard
  • Community rules

Deliberately generous. A crippled free tier gets abandoned before it ever demonstrates value. This must be genuinely useful on its own.


Paid

The line follows SonarQube's proven split: single-branch analysis is free, everything a team needs is paid.

Team tier

  • Pull request and merge request decoration
  • Branch and feature-branch analysis
  • Multi-project portfolio view
  • SSO (SAML, OIDC)
  • Role-based access control
  • Historical trends beyond 30 days

Enterprise tier

  • Policy management across projects
  • Audit logs
  • SBOM attestation and signing
  • Custom rule authoring UI
  • Priority support and SLA
  • Air-gapped deployment support

Hosted SaaS

  • Everything above with zero deployment work
  • Per-repository or per-developer pricing
  • The lowest-friction path to first revenue, and where a solo founder should focus

Commercial licence

  • For organisations that cannot use AGPL
  • Priced per organisation, not per seat

Pricing

Deliberately unset. Anchor against current SonarQube and Snyk list pricing when you get there, and undercut on the per-developer SaaS tier — that is where both incumbents are weakest for teams under 200 engineers.

Validate with real buyers before publishing numbers.


Repository split

Paid features do not live in this repository.

sonarquest-dev        public, AGPL-3.0   — engine, scanners, core, CLI, dashboard
sonarquest-enterprise private            — SSO, RBAC, PR decoration, policy, audit
sonarquest-cloud      private            — hosted SaaS, billing, tenancy

The private repos consume the public one as a dependency. Never invert that — an AGPL core importing proprietary code is a licence violation.


Upstream licence constraints

The scanners this product wraps have their own terms. These are hard constraints on what can ship.

Tool Licence Constraint
OpenGrep LGPL-2.1 Execute as a subprocess. Never link or vendor the binary.
Syft Apache-2.0 No constraint
Grype Apache-2.0 No constraint
OSV Open data No constraint
ScanCode Apache-2.0 No constraint

Semgrep is excluded. Its engine is LGPL-2.1, but its maintained rules moved to the Semgrep Rules License v1.0 in December 2024 — internal, non-competing, non-SaaS use only. A commercial SAST platform is precisely what that excludes. OpenGrep is the LGPL-2.1 fork built for this situation, governed by a consortium of appsec vendors rather than a single competitor.

Rule sources must be checked individually. Registry rules inherit the licence of their source repository — some are AGPL-3.0, some are proprietary. Ship only rules that are OSS-licensed or written in-house.