Skip to content

QUALITY_SCORE.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
69 lines (55 loc) · 4.07 KB

QUALITY_SCORE.md

File metadata and controls

69 lines (55 loc) · 4.07 KB
Raw

Quality Score — fellowship-dev/flowchad

Last updated: 2026-05-25

Domains

Domain Grade Last audit Notes
flowchad-setup B 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅ (docs 2026-05-01 > code 2026-05-21), S4 ✅ (3 open), S6 ❌
flow-walk C 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ⚠️ (4 open), S6 ❌
flow-report C 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ⚠️ (5 open), S6 ❌
flow-add C 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ⚠️ (5 open), S6 ❌
flow-suggest B 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ✅ (1 open), S6 ❌
flow-diff B 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ✅ (3 open), S6 ❌
flow-diagram B 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ✅ (2 open), S6 ❌
flow-update C 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ⚠️ (4 open), S6 ❌
evidence-upload B 2026-05-21 S1 ✅, S3 ✅, S4 ✅ (0 open), S6 ❌
flow-reproduce B 2026-05-25 S1 ✅, S3 ✅ (new — same day), S4 ✅ (0 open), S6 ❌

Signal Matrix

Domain S1 Doc S2 FlowChad S3 Stale S4 Issues S5 Tests S6 Hookshot
flowchad-setup ✅ N/A ✅ (scripts 2026-05-21 (4d)) ✅ (3) N/A ❌
flow-walk ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ⚠️ (4) N/A ❌
flow-report ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ⚠️ (5) N/A ❌
flow-add ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ⚠️ (5) N/A ❌
flow-suggest ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ✅ (1) N/A ❌
flow-diff ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ✅ (3) N/A ❌
flow-diagram ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ✅ (2) N/A ❌
flow-update ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ⚠️ (4) N/A ❌
evidence-upload ✅ N/A ✅ (docs>code) ✅ (0) N/A ❌
flow-reproduce ✅ N/A ✅ (new 2026-05-25) ✅ (0) N/A ❌

Signal Applicability

Signal Applicable? Reason
S1 Doc Coverage Yes README.md covers all 10 domains with descriptions and quick-start
S2 FlowChad No Tool repo — no frontend framework; .flowchad/flows/ is empty by design (template)
S3 Staleness Yes README last updated 2026-05-01; scripts last commit 2026-05-21 (PR #39 — update mechanism) ✅
S4 Open Issues Yes 6 total open issues across repo
S5 Tests No No test infrastructure detected
S6 Hookshot Yes Not configured ❌

Grade Summary

  • A: 0
  • B: 6 (flowchad-setup, flow-suggest, flow-diff, flow-diagram, evidence-upload, flow-reproduce)
  • C: 4 (flow-walk, flow-report, flow-add, flow-update)
  • D: 0

Methodology note (2026-05-18): S6 corrected from N/A to applicable per entropy-check spec. Previous A grades (flow-suggest, flow-diff, flow-diagram, evidence-upload) now B due to S6 ❌. C grades reflect S6 ❌ + S4 ⚠️ (4-5 open issues). S3 ✅ across all domains — README updated 2026-05-01 is ahead of scripts (2026-04-17).

Dispatched This Run

  • #20 — Update mechanism + drift detection for drop-in installs (P1) — PR #39 in double-check review (6/7 items done; "Register on skills.sh registry" remains open)

History

Date Trigger Summary
2026-04-24 weekly sweep 9 domains; setup B, walk B, report B, add B, suggest A, diff A, diagram A, update B, upload A. S6 incorrectly excluded.
2026-05-18 weekly sweep S6 methodology corrected. 5 B-grades, 4 C-grades. 0 real regressions (all changes are S6 correction + updated issue counts).
2026-05-19 daily sweep 9 domains, 0 regressions, 0 improvements. All signals stable.
2026-05-21 daily sweep 9 domains, 0 regressions, 0 improvements. Dispatched #20 (P1, update mechanism).
2026-05-21 PR #39 double-check Updated S3 staleness for flowchad-setup (scripts updated). #20 6/7 items in PR; "Register on skills.sh registry" remains open.
2026-05-25 daily sweep 9 domains, 0 regressions, 0 improvements. S3 4d ✅. WIP=0. Dispatched #28 (P1, customer bug reproduction).
2026-05-25 issue #28 10 domains. Added flow-reproduce (B). 0 regressions to existing skills.