evaluation.yml

name: Prototype Evaluation
description: Score a submission against the evaluation rubric
title: "[Evaluation]: "
labels: ["under-review"]
body:
  - type: markdown
    attributes:
      value: |
        ## Prototype Evaluation
        Score the submission against each rubric criterion (0-5). Provide comments to justify your scores. Be specific — the submitter deserves honest, actionable feedback.

  - type: input
    id: submission-reference
    attributes:
      label: Submission Reference
      description: The issue number of the prototype submission being evaluated.
      placeholder: "#123"
    validations:
      required: true

  - type: markdown
    attributes:
      value: |
        ---
        ### Business Value
        Does this solve a real problem with measurable impact? Is the dollar value framing credible?

  - type: dropdown
    id: business-value-score
    attributes:
      label: Business Value Score
      options:
        - "0"
        - "1"
        - "2"
        - "3"
        - "4"
        - "5"
    validations:
      required: true

  - type: textarea
    id: business-value-comments
    attributes:
      label: Business Value Comments
      description: Justify your score. What's strong? What's missing?
      placeholder: "Explain your reasoning..."

  - type: markdown
    attributes:
      value: |
        ---
        ### Technical Feasibility
        Can this actually be built to production quality? Are the technical choices sound?

  - type: dropdown
    id: technical-feasibility-score
    attributes:
      label: Technical Feasibility Score
      options:
        - "0"
        - "1"
        - "2"
        - "3"
        - "4"
        - "5"
    validations:
      required: true

  - type: textarea
    id: technical-feasibility-comments
    attributes:
      label: Technical Feasibility Comments
      description: Justify your score. What's strong? What's missing?
      placeholder: "Explain your reasoning..."

  - type: markdown
    attributes:
      value: |
        ---
        ### Resource Efficiency
        Is the ask reasonable relative to the value? Can this be done with minimal investment?

  - type: dropdown
    id: resource-efficiency-score
    attributes:
      label: Resource Efficiency Score
      options:
        - "0"
        - "1"
        - "2"
        - "3"
        - "4"
        - "5"
    validations:
      required: true

  - type: textarea
    id: resource-efficiency-comments
    attributes:
      label: Resource Efficiency Comments
      description: Justify your score. What's strong? What's missing?
      placeholder: "Explain your reasoning..."

  - type: markdown
    attributes:
      value: |
        ---
        ### Strategic Alignment
        Does this align with where the organization is heading? Does it support stated priorities?

  - type: dropdown
    id: strategic-alignment-score
    attributes:
      label: Strategic Alignment Score
      options:
        - "0"
        - "1"
        - "2"
        - "3"
        - "4"
        - "5"
    validations:
      required: true

  - type: textarea
    id: strategic-alignment-comments
    attributes:
      label: Strategic Alignment Comments
      description: Justify your score. What's strong? What's missing?
      placeholder: "Explain your reasoning..."

  - type: markdown
    attributes:
      value: |
        ---
        ### Innovation Factor
        Is this genuinely novel? Does it challenge assumptions or introduce a new approach?

  - type: dropdown
    id: innovation-factor-score
    attributes:
      label: Innovation Factor Score
      options:
        - "0"
        - "1"
        - "2"
        - "3"
        - "4"
        - "5"
    validations:
      required: true

  - type: textarea
    id: innovation-factor-comments
    attributes:
      label: Innovation Factor Comments
      description: Justify your score. What's strong? What's missing?
      placeholder: "Explain your reasoning..."

  - type: markdown
    attributes:
      value: |
        ---
        ### Overall Recommendation

  - type: dropdown
    id: overall-recommendation
    attributes:
      label: Overall Recommendation
      description: Based on your scores, what should happen with this prototype?
      options:
        - Graduate
        - Iterate
        - Shelve
        - Kill
    validations:
      required: true

  - type: textarea
    id: additional-comments
    attributes:
      label: Additional Comments
      description: Any other feedback, concerns, or suggestions for the submitter.
      placeholder: "Anything else the submitter or review panel should know..."