[Health 11.0.0] Double step count from Health Connect when there are multiple sources and excluding manual entry

[KWM0]

Device / Emulator and OS

• Device: Samsung S20FE 5G
• OS: Android 13

Describe the bug

Getting nearly double the steps when retrieve steps from health package when excluding manual entry and multiple sources (Google Fit and Samsung Health) in Health Connect.

To Reproduce

Retrieving steps from getTotalStepsInInterval and includeManualEntry: false

Expected behavior

Only retrieve the step data from 1 source when excluding manual entry

Actual behavior

Currently retrieved all the step data together from all sources (Google Fit and Samsung Health) when excluding manual entry.

Screenshots

[mukhtarfauzi]

is there any update?
I do have the same behavior with each health app that counts steps as well, it has more steps counted

[iarata]

@KWM0 @mukhtarfauzi The HealthDataPoint have sourcePlatform and sourceDeviceId attributes. Why you're not filtering the data points based on these attributes?

[iarata]

Also take a look at getHealthDataFromTypes() function where you can specify a list of recordingMethodsToFilter

[alvinthen]

We rely on getTotalStepsInInterval because in iOS, Apple Health will aggregate the step count if there are multiple sources (iPhone + Apple Watch). If we get manually via getHealthDataFromTypes, we will have to manually aggregate to remove duplicates, and removeDuplicates doesn't really help.

Although this is an Android issue, we are hoping that the behavior is similar to iOS