Skip to content

Collaboration request: external gyrokinetic validation artefacts #47

@anulum

Description

@anulum

Blocked modules

  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_eigenvalue.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_interface.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_nonlinear.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_geometry.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_species.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/jax_gk_solver.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_ood_detector.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gyrokinetic_transport.py
  • src/scpn_control/core/gk_online_learner.py

Needed evidence

  • Real TGLF, GENE, GS2, CGYRO, or QuaLiKiz executable runs or documented public reference outputs.
  • Native-vs-external benchmark cases with identical Miller geometry and species inputs.
  • Input decks, raw external outputs, parsed outputs, growth rates, real frequencies, and parser artefacts.
  • Long nonlinear Cyclone Base Case saturation campaigns with solver convergence and late-time heat-flux traces.
  • Published or cross-code saturated heat-flux references.
  • Independent Miller-geometry reference cases for circular, shaped, and high-shear equilibria.
  • Published gyrokinetic or Fokker-Planck collision reference cases.
  • CPU/GPU JAX parity artefacts with backend, platform, dtype, X64, tolerance, growth-rate, and real-frequency metadata.
  • Real or published GK campaign ensembles for OOD threshold calibration and online learner held-out distribution-shift tests.

Claim unblocked

Quantitative gyrokinetic agreement and accelerator-equivalent physics claims. Until these artefacts exist, local implementation and parser tests remain bounded validation only.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    blocked-by-dataBlocked by unavailable external/reference datacollaboration-wantedExternal collaborators can provide artefacts or reviewexternal-validationRequires external code/data/hardware evidencehelp wantedExtra attention is neededphysics-validationPhysics validation and benchmark evidenceroadmapTracked on roadmap

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions